Sullivan County weekend / Pro-RD rant

We recently visited a friend’s Sullivan County, New York weekend house for a couple of days. Something about getting out of the city and being in the country ignites my passion for local food, in-season produce, and home-grown homemade meals. Our hosts didn’t disappoint: lettuce, chives, cilantro, basil, shallots, scallions, zucchini, and baby fingerling potatoes from their garden made for some good eatin’.  (The setting didn’t disappoint either: tranquility, stunning sunsets, hummingbirds, butterflies, and more.)

The sun sets on Sullivan Co.

While there, I picked up this month’s issue of GQ magazine and read a wonderfully engaging article about ethical eating by Alan Richman (“Eat No Evil” – not available on-line).  Mr. Richman examines many aspects of what has become a hot trend in food, driven in part by books like The Omnivore’s Dilemma.  He interviewed farmers and self-proclaimed ethical eaters to try to come to an understanding of what it really means to eat ethically.  Among the issues raised: the question, ‘is it better to buy the local-but-conventional food, the organic-but-imported food, or the organic-but-industrial one?’ – a debate I often have when shopping at FreshDirect, my on-line grocer here in NYC, which has products in all of those categories.

When you consider the nutrition, the environmental impact, animal rights issues, and labor issues relating to the foods we eat, you begin to sense that there’s no clear roadmap to ethical eating. Richman basically concludes that eaters must reconcile their options and choose for themselves what they feel is the “right” path, through mindful eating and conscious consumerism.

My only criticism of the article, and the reason I was moved to write about it, is that on page 130 Mr. Richman states, “only your doctor or your mother should tell you what to eat.” What?!  I beg your pardon, Mr. Richman, but REGISTERED DIETITIANS are the nation’s food and nutrition experts. Doctors, with all due respect, are not.

Now, I’ve said my piece. I’m off to eat dinner: a hamburger (made from ground beef from a cow raised on a small family farm which is not certified “organic” but is a farm where I know the animals are treated humanely and allowed time in a pasture instead of kept in an industrial livestock feedlot) on a bun made in a factory in who-knows-where with whole (but conventionally grown) grains and some artificial preservatives added for shelf stability, with plenty of Heinz ketchup (not the organic kind) on top. On the side is broccoli – organic but (gasp!) frozen and delivered in an airplane from California to my store in New York.   And I ask myself, is this an “ethical” meal?

Um… Well…

Ethical enough.



Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “Sullivan County weekend / Pro-RD rant

  1. jenny

    amy, great blog! The article you mentioned reminds me of a book i just read called “farewell my subaru” by doug fine in which he tries to lessen his carbon footprint by moving to new mexico and buying a ranch. he talks a lot about buying locally instead of just organically because of the carbon print made when produce is shipped all over. I guess we all need to eat local and learn to love the produce during the season it is actually grown.
    check out the book – it is hysterical!

  2. Janelle

    I read that article too—and am still stumped—better to buy the local-but-conventional food, the organic-but-imported food, or the organic-but-industrial one? i do a combo of all three. buying as much as i can on sundays at our farmer’s market: fruits, veggies, milk, eggs, etc. we did a buyer’s club all winter for our meat and they are at a saturday market during the summer. and i try to remember that just because whole foods sells it doesn’t mean it’s magical. meanwhile my kids love chicken nuggets (i buy the good ones), goldfish (whole grain), and chocolate milk (organic.)

  3. Donna

    Thank you for making me feel sane! I am not worried about feeding children (because I do not have any) but I am conscious about how I feed myself. The millions of guidelines out there can make a single, crazy hour working, trying to fit in a workout, and trying to manage a life, person go crazy! Love your blog, will share with my friends.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s